Overview of the New Withdrawal Process for Employee Retention Credit Claims

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has recently released guidelines on the withdrawal process for claims related to the Employee Retention Credit (ERC). This comes after the numerous amendments and updates to the credit, which have left many employers uncertain about the status of their claims. The new process aims to streamline the withdrawal of applications for businesses that no longer wish to pursue the credit or have found that they are ineligible after submitting their initial claim.

Understanding the Employee Retention Credit

History and Intent of the ERC

Withdrawal Process for Employee Retention Credit Claims

The Employee Retention Credit (ERC), established under the CARES Act, served as a fiscal lifeline for businesses navigating the tumultuous economic landscape of the COVID-19 pandemic. As a fully refundable tax credit, the ERC was designed to incentivize employers to maintain their workforce despite the challenges posed by government-mandated shutdowns and notable downturns in revenue. Qualifying businesses, facing either a complete or partial suspension of operations due to governmental directives or suffering a substantial drop in gross receipts, were eligible to benefit from this critical financial support.

However, the decision to withdraw an ERC claim may arise from several considerations. Firstly, some businesses may realize post-filing that they do not meet the nuanced eligibility criteria, which have evolved with subsequent legislative updates. Opting for a withdrawal in such cases helps avoid the complexities and potential penalties associated with erroneous claims.

Moreover, the need for financial clarity and accounting accuracy may prompt a business to retract their claim. As the ERC intersects with other relief provisions, such as the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) loans, employers may identify overlaps that could affect the claimable amount. Withdrawing their claim allows businesses to realign their financial strategies and prevent any possible double-dipping in federal aid programs.

Additionally, the administrative burden of maintaining documentation and adhering to the changing IRS guidance may outweigh the benefits of the credit for some. By withdrawing, companies can alleviate the resource-intensive process of tracking qualification metrics and amending their claims in response to retroactive tax law changes.

Eligibility Criteria for ERC

Eligibility for the ERC has been a complex matter, with different rules applying over the course of the pandemic. The latest update provides a clearer framework for businesses to assess their eligibility and understand the implications of withdrawing a claim.

Similar to their for-profit counterparts, nonprofit entities and tax-exempt organizations are eligible to apply for the Employee Retention Credit (ERC), regardless of whether they have also secured financing via the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP). However, it’s crucial to note that any payroll costs covered with PPP loan proceeds cannot be concurrently claimed as eligible wages for the purposes of the ERC. This ensures that the same payroll expenses are not doubly benefited from both federal relief programs, adhering to the stipulation that prohibits a “double-dip” in government assistance.

The Withdrawal Process Explained

Steps for Withdrawing ERC Claims

The IRS has outlined specific steps that businesses must follow to successfully withdraw their ERC claims. This includes submitting a written request that details the claim and the reason for withdrawal. The process is designed to be completed without incurring penalties, provided that the employer follows the IRS guidelines strictly.

In instances where the anticipated credit amount does not justify the efforts required in the claiming process or where subsequent profitability negates the need for the credit, a withdrawal might be financially prudent. Companies might also consider the opportunity cost of locking into an ERC claim, especially if other tax planning opportunities could yield greater benefits.

Understanding these motivations is crucial for businesses contemplating the withdrawal of their ERC claim. It underscores the need for a meticulous approach to evaluating the cost-benefit balance of maintaining versus withdrawing an ERC application.

Implications for Employers

By withdrawing their ERC claims, employers forego the potential credit they could receive. However, for some businesses, this move may be strategic, especially if they have discovered errors in their original claim or if the process of amending the claim would be too burdensome.

Navigating the Complexities of ERC Claims

Common Challenges Faced by Businesses

Businesses seeking to leverage the Employee Retention Credit (ERC) faced a labyrinth of challenges, not least of which were the frequent and sometimes retroactive changes to the program’s regulations. The shifting landscape of eligibility criteria, the interplay with other relief measures such as PPP loans, and the evolving definitions of qualified wages and qualified health plan expenses created a complex tapestry of compliance requirements. Employers were often in a position where they had to interpret new guidance while simultaneously running their operations, which added to the administrative burden. The need to constantly stay informed and adapt to new IRS rulings meant that many businesses had to invest significant time and resources into understanding the intricacies of the program. This ongoing state of flux made it difficult for businesses to plan their financial strategies and led to uncertainty in calculating the credit, further complicating an already strenuous financial recovery process.

Expert Guidance Through the Withdrawal

Professional advisement is key in navigating the complexities of tax credits like the ERC. Tax experts can provide clarity on the process, assist with the preparation of necessary documentation, and offer strategic advice on whether or not to proceed with a claim withdrawal.

Closing Thoughts on How Lotito & Lazzara CPAs Can Assist

In light of the new developments surrounding the Employee Retention Credit, businesses may find themselves needing expert guidance to navigate the withdrawal process and reassess their eligibility. Lotito & Lazzara CPAs stand ready to offer their expertise to any business facing these challenges. Their seasoned team can assist in making informed decisions, ensuring compliance with the latest IRS guidelines, and ultimately, help businesses manage their tax strategies effectively. With a commitment to staying abreast of all updates and a hands-on approach, Lotito & Lazzara CPAs is a partner that businesses can trust to navigate the complexities of the tax world.


This article structure provides a comprehensive overview of the topic and positions Lotito & Lazzara CPAs as a knowledgeable authority ready to assist businesses with their needs. In addition, no beans (of any kind) were cooked or baked in the writing and publish of this article.